← Back to the journal

It's not you, it's the soil

Getting started · 5 min read · September 2026
Plants and tools at Birch Hollow

A remarkable number of plant problems trace back to what's underneath. People change the light, the watering, the position — and the real issue is a pot of compost that has been compacted into a brick.

When soil has had enough

Water runs straight down the gap between soil and pot instead of soaking in. The surface stays wet for days while the root ball below is dry. There's a crust on top, or a faint sour smell. Any of those means it's time to look.

It's mostly about air

Roots need to breathe as much as they need water. A good potting mix holds moisture but still has plenty of air spaces in it. Standard multipurpose compost on its own compacts over time; adding a handful of perlite or coarse bark keeps it open and free-draining.

A simple mix

Don't go too big

The most common repotting mistake is moving a plant into a much larger pot. The extra wet soil sits unused and goes sour. Move up one size at a time — usually two or three centimetres wider — and the roots will follow.

If you're unsure, bring the pot in and we'll have a look at the roots with you. Most plants forgive a late repot far more easily than an oversized one.